SIDNEY – A 20-calendar year-previous male who explained he stabbed his cousin to death in self protection was found not guilty of voluntary manslaughter Thursday afternoon by a Shelby County jury.
Riley Daniel Barger by no means denied that he brought about the death of his cousin, 27-year-aged Brianna Wilson, on the afternoon of Feb. 5. Nonetheless, he stated she attacked him that working day and he only stabbed her in self defense.
“I was afraid,” Barger said of that afternoon. “I was afraid for my daily life.”
Both of those the prosecution and protection agreed on nearly all of the circumstance information assume for irrespective of whether or not Barger’s stabbing of Wilson was justified. Prosecutor Tim Promote also questioned no matter whether Barger’s account of the combat that finished in the stabbing happened particularly as he experienced explained.
“He introduced a knife to a cat struggle,” Offer mentioned.
Barger had moved into Wilson’s house at 630 Fourth Ave. in Sidney in late December 2020 when he necessary a place to stay for a pair times. Barger stated Wilson allowed him to stay more time whilst they and one particular other roommate searched for work collectively as they intended to carpool to perform.
Having said that, extra than a thirty day period later on, Wilson grew worn out of Barger dwelling at the residence and not contributing economically. She desired him to shift out and threw his belongings outdoors in the snow on Feb. 5.
Immediately after Barger referred to as the Sidney Law enforcement Office, officers Jim Jennings and Scott White explained to Wilson she would have to go as a result of the eviction course of action. In the meantime, Barger experienced a ideal to be in the house, they reported.
“We knowledgeable her that she experienced to file for eviction,” White explained. “She stated she comprehended that but nonetheless wasn’t heading to allow him to go back into the dwelling.”
The officers also told Barger he was authorized to split into the house to get accessibility. When he pushed in a window, a further confrontation ensued, and Wilson shoved Barger.
Officers, who returned to the residence, once again told Wilson she had to enable Barger inside of and still left the scene at the time extra, stating arguments like that were being typical and there was no purpose to believe more violence would come about.
Times later Wilson termed an uncle, Darrin Opphile, who also had been staying at the residence, to arrive and enable.
“She reported, ‘I’m heading to jail. Remember to get below,’” Opphile claimed.
The prosecution claimed the jail remark referred to her disobeying the law enforcement orders about allowing Barger in the house. The defense instructed it was a menace.
Wilson earlier was charged with capturing her boyfriend, whom she claimed experienced tried out to destroy her.
“She suggests, ‘Riley, I just shot a particular person. Do you actually feel I will not f*** you up?’” Barger explained.
Though Wilson known as Opphile, Barger went into the home and was in the method of bringing an close desk up the stairs when Wilson grabbed it from guiding. He explained she also grabbed his hair and dragged him backwards, a declare the prosecution disputed.
At that place the cellphone video Barger was recording ended, leaving the subsequent few moments unclear.
Barger mentioned Wilson pushed him down, scratching and punching him from driving – an assertion that was at minimum partially verified by scratches on Barger’s nose and all around his eye.
Barger also said Wilson, who weighed practically three instances as a lot as him, wouldn’t let him up as he struggled to breath.
“I explained to her I believe I’m heading to die,” Barger, who reported he has asthma, said. “I begged for her to get off of me.
“The past thing she claims is she does not treatment if I die.”
Barger said he pulled a pocket knife from his coat pocket. With his left hand, he flailed it in the path of Wilson to endeavor to totally free himself.
He then was equipped to get out from less than her, he claimed, shortly soon after which Opphile arrived at the house and instructed him to depart. Opphile referred to as 911 and executed CPR until finally police and paramedics arrived.
Barger ran outside to his girlfriend’s motor vehicle and also termed 911. He approached White when the officer returned to the house.
“I just wanted my stuff back,” Barger, also coughing and vomiting, reported on a system cam video clip.
Barger stated he was laying on his belly with Wilson on prime of him all through the stabbing, utilizing his left arm to stab her. She was stabbed 6 periods – twice in the back, as soon as in the again of the head, once on her appropriate arm, as soon as near her suitable armpit and a lethal blow that penetrated 4 inches into her heart.
Nevertheless, Dr. Kent Harshbarger, the Montgomery County coroner who carried out an autopsy on Wilson, claimed it didn’t seem to be attainable for Wilson’s injuries to come about in the method Barger explained. Both she or the weapon had to move, Harshbarger said, though there’s no way to decide the actual positions of the two individuals.
“She has to be just about back to his back again to make that pathway do the job,” the coroner stated.
Market stated Harshbarger’s testimony need to influence the jury that Barger was lying about what happened. He also questioned why Barger did not have a lot more injuries outside of his deal with and hands if Wilson was on top of him, why she didn’t have injuries to her palms if she was punching him and how blood was splattered in the course of the room if all the stabs transpired in a single site.
“It is not feasible that these accidents were being sustained as he suggests,” Offer reported. “It’s not. So if his act of killing her, if he lies to you about that, if he lies to you about that, I believe your common sense would convey to you you just can’t consider what he has to say.”
Defense attorney Laura Waymire said the actions of the two individuals through the combat furthermore Barger retrieving his cellular phone ahead of he left the property contributed to the blood splatter.
She also said if Barger experienced intended to kill his cousin, much more than just one of the stab wounds ought to have penetrated further.
“If Riley attacked her in a in shape of rage, why only 1?” Waymire explained. “Riley defended himself towards a violent, indignant, aggressive man or woman.
“He understands of her violent previous. He is aware what she’s able of.
“Riley was in a situation that he observed no other way out of.”
All through a video clip interview later on that day at the Sidney Law enforcement Division, Barger broke down in tears when he was educated that Wilson had died of her accidents.
“I did not want this to come about,” he reported while crying.
The demo, with browsing Decide Stacy M. Wall from Miami County, lasted three times. The jury used close to two and a 50 percent hrs deliberating the demand before returning the not guilty verdict, at which time Barger was allowed to go absolutely free.
Riley Barger waits for his jury trial to start off on Tuesday, Aug. 4, in Shelby County Popular Pleas Courtroom.
Get to the author at [email protected] or 937-538-4824.